[Stained Class]

Yeah, that would be a solid lineup! Did you count my list? I didn't actually post it I just have it in my sig. No repeats there either! Well done pplz!

Yep!! Totally included all your list

Excellent. I wonder how far off that is! I see a bunch of bands there that are pretty likely. Right before we go on the next one necro this thread so we can make comparisons.

[KevinP]

Latest update - including new wishlists, and The Sultan's Kreator request :)

12 - Kreator, King Diamond/Merciful Fate, Immortal, Helloween
11 - Running Wild, Hypocrisy
09 - Accept
08 - Arkona
07 - Turisas, Symphony X, Opeth, Kalmah, Enslaved, Arch Enemy
06 - UneXpect, Powerwolf, Madder Mortem, Heathen, Devin Townsend, Crimson Glory, Bolt Thrower
05 - Within Temptation, W.A.S.P, Septic Flesh, Satyricon, Rotting Christ, Rhapsody of Fire, Paradise Lost, Heidevolk, Falconer, Dethklok, At the Gates, Anthrax, Agalloch

34 bands with 5 requests or more. Give me those 34 and a few fillers, and count me in

That would be one helluva lineup indeed. It's works fine for 70K due to variety, but not so much for Barge. If I whittled it down for BTH, it would look like:

12 - Kreator, King Diamond/Merciful Fate, Immortal
11 - Hypocrisy
09 - Accept
08 - Arkona
07 - Opeth, Kalmah, Enslaved, Arch Enemy
06 - UneXpect, Powerwolf, Madder Mortem, Heathen, Bolt Thrower
05 - Septic Flesh, Satyricon, Rotting Christ, Paradise Lost, Dethklok, At the Gates, Anthrax, Agalloch

I'm of the belief that kick ass old school metal, which is generally loved by the "extreme fan", definitely fits in there. Powerwolf also fits the theme for me. Not a huge or rabid fan, but the makeup and subject matter would fit right in.

[DrinkMoxie]

Statsman... your compiled list has a disheartening lack of Ne Obliviscaris

[Invective]

Artillery
Flotsam and Jetsam
Bloodbath
Sacrifice!
Kreator!
Gama Bomb
Striker
ACCEPT!!!
Demons and Wizards!!
Sacred Reich!
Dekapitator/Exhumed
Hobbs' Angel of Death
Into Eternity
Zimmers Hole (would be HILARIOUS on board!!)
Pentagram (hopefully they rebook!)
Razor!
RIGOR MORTIS!
Heathen
Hail of Bullets/Asphyx

one repeat - BLIND GUARDIAN! They should be the house band!

The number one bad I know would never get added but I would probably DIE if they did - TENACIOUS D. Could you imagine?!!?

[KevinP]

- TENACIOUS D. Could you imagine?!!?

Well they would be fun, but I don't actually spend time daydreaming about the possibility.

Does that answer your question ?

[Invective]

- TENACIOUS D. Could you imagine?!!?

Well they would be fun, but I don't actually spend time daydreaming about the possibility.

Does that answer your question ?

Your loins don't quiver for Jack Black?

[cowboy71]

Statsman... your compiled list has a disheartening lack of Ne Obliviscaris

Your's is the only vote so far - you need to pimp 'em harder

[Stained Class]

Statsman... your compiled list has a disheartening lack of Ne Obliviscaris

Knew I forgot someone, just added to my list

The number one bad I know would never get added but I would probably DIE if they did - TENACIOUS D. Could you imagine?!!?

Fuck yeah, new album coming out this year, I imagine they'll be touring. I would LOVE to see this band. Hanging with Jack Black would be awesome too.

[DrinkMoxie]

Statsman... your compiled list has a disheartening lack of Ne Obliviscaris

Knew I forgot someone, just added to my list

good man! and I think I neglected Myrath on mine... time to fix

[cowboy71]

Cool - made note of all that. Will probably update the listing on a daily basis from now on depending on how many wishlists and how often that people post.

And for doing this all I ask is....

[Stained Class]

Cool - made note of all that. Will probably update the listing on a daily basis from now on depending on how many wishlists and how often that people post.

And for doing this all I ask is....

Don't work too hard statsman. Unless your at work, in which case spend as much time on these forums as you'd like

[Jebus_Cripes]

Fuck yeah, new album coming out this year, I imagine they'll be touring. I would LOVE to see this band. Hanging with Jack Black would be awesome too.

That would be awesome but Jack Black would be harrassed everywhere he goes on the boat. He seems like the type of person that would be ok with it though.

[Stained Class]

Fuck yeah, new album coming out this year, I imagine they'll be touring. I would LOVE to see this band. Hanging with Jack Black would be awesome too.

That would be awesome but Jack Black would be harrassed everywhere he goes on the boat. He seems like the type of person that would be ok with it though.

Yeah, well the thing is I'm not sure he would be that much more well known than Corpsegrinder, I mean most of everyone on the boat probably knew what he looks like. We're pretty chill too so we wouldn't be like tackling him and trying to steal bits of his hair. He's very outgoing so I'm sure he'd be fine.

[Alex Fields]

Lacuna Coil
Avantasia
Allen & Lande
Nightwish
Tarot
Within Temptation
Sons of Seasons
Epica
Sonata Arctica
Iced Earth
Symphony X
Syrens Call
Apocalyptica
Dimmu Borgir
Powerwolf
Helloween
Northern Kings
Delain
Therion
Eluveitie
Mago de Oz
Disturbed

[mooyagi]

The number one bad I know would never get added but I would probably DIE if they did - TENACIOUS D. Could you imagine?!!?

Fuck yeah, new album coming out this year, I imagine they'll be touring. I would LOVE to see this band. Hanging with Jack Black would be awesome too.

That would be awesome. Jack Black would have a blast on the ship

[Michael D.]

My list begins.
Accept
Anvil
Apocalyptica
Arkona
Avantasia
Krokus
Immortal
Rage Against the Machine
Opeth
Scorpions
TOOL
Within Temptation

[cowboy71]

*update*

13 - Helloween, Immortal, Kreator
12 - King Diamond/Merciful Fate
11 - Accept, Hypocrisy, Running Wild
09 - Arkona
08 - Opeth, Symphony X
07 - Arch Enemy, Enslaved, Heathen, Kalmah, Powerwolf, Turisas, Within Temptation
06 - Bolt Thrower, Crimson Glory, Devin Townsend/SYL, Madder Mortem, UneXpect
05 - Agalloch, Anthrax, Anvil, Artillery, At The Gates, Demons & Wizards, Dethklok, Falconer, Heidevolk, Paradise Lost, Pentagram, Rhapsody of Fire, Rotting Christ, Satyricon, Septic Flesh, W.A.S.P.

38 bands now - almost a full boat

[AlaskaRachel]

*update*

13 - Helloween, Immortal, Kreator
12 - King Diamond/Merciful Fate
11 - Accept, Hypocrisy, Running Wild
09 - Arkona
08 - Opeth, Symphony X
07 - Arch Enemy, Enslaved, Heathen, Kalmah, Powerwolf, Turisas, Within Temptation
06 - Bolt Thrower, Crimson Glory, Devin Townsend/SYL, Madder Mortem, UneXpect
05 - Agalloch, Anthrax, Anvil, Artillery, At The Gates, Demons & Wizards, Dethklok, Falconer, Heidevolk, Paradise Lost, Pentagram, Rhapsody of Fire, Rotting Christ, Satyricon, Septic Flesh, W.A.S.P.

38 bands now - almost a full boat

Now all Andy has to do is start making phone calls!

[KDibildeaux]

Quite happy to see MADDER MORTEM with 6 requests.

And just think, if Wizardbeast used all her energy for pimping them, as opposed to her useless banter with the MCM and that dude who likes shitty sports teams, the would get even more "play".

And the only reason Menmoch doesn't like Unexpect is that he likes his female singers overly sappy to the Nth degree

I think you're jealous. It's okay! you can join our witty banter anytime!

You didn't have any earplugs.
And I thought I saw you pleasuring yourself in the kiddy pool during their set. A terrible thing to witness, it was.

[mooyagi]

*update*

13 - Helloween, Immortal, Kreator
12 - King Diamond/Merciful Fate
11 - Accept, Hypocrisy, Running Wild
09 - Arkona
08 - Opeth, Symphony X
07 - Arch Enemy, Enslaved, Heathen, Kalmah, Powerwolf, Turisas, Within Temptation
06 - Bolt Thrower, Crimson Glory, Devin Townsend/SYL, Madder Mortem, UneXpect
05 - Agalloch, Anthrax, Anvil, Artillery, At The Gates, Demons & Wizards, Dethklok, Falconer, Heidevolk, Paradise Lost, Pentagram, Rhapsody of Fire, Rotting Christ, Satyricon, Septic Flesh, W.A.S.P.

38 bands now - almost a full boat

Now all Andy has to do is start making phone calls!

That's a really, really good cruise right there

[DragonLordJones]

we need more people pimping MOTORHEAD ........ lol damn it

[MadameLePink]

My wishlist is the same as my signature, minus Moonsorrow and Overkill I would love some repeats from 2011, but I guess it won't happen :(

[Stained Class]

My wishlist is the same as my signature, minus Moonsorrow and Overkill I would love some repeats from 2011, but I guess it won't happen :(

Won't happen? I'd be amazed if it didn't happen.

[mooyagi]

My wishlist is the same as my signature, minus Moonsorrow and Overkill I would love some repeats from 2011, but I guess it won't happen :(

Won't happen? I'd be amazed if it didn't happen.

Same here. I expect a couple of repeats this time around.

[MadameLePink]

My wishlist is the same as my signature, minus Moonsorrow and Overkill I would love some repeats from 2011, but I guess it won't happen :(

Won't happen? I'd be amazed if it didn't happen.

Same here. I expect a couple of repeats this time around.

Do you really think there will be repeats? I thought it was out of the question as there are many bands that would like to be onbroad :) Of course I would be thrilled if they announced Ensiferum, Finntroll, Korpiklaani, Amon Amarth, Testament and Dark Tranquillity

[Memnoch]

I know this saddens Kevin, but I think Nightwish won't be onbroad next time, as I'd assume there will be no repeats from 2012. I too think there will be a couple of repeats from 2011.

[mooyagi]

Do you really think there will be repeats? I thought it was out of the question as there are many bands that would like to be onbroad :) Of course I would be thrilled if they announced Ensiferum, Finntroll, Korpiklaani, Amon Amarth, Testament and Dark Tranquillity

I'm not expecting a lot, just a couple. Many of the first cruise bands really want to play it again. I figure it would be easy to get them booked and Andy may even be able to give a couple of them a "lowball" offer to come back because they liked it so much. Could save some budget for headliner types. I wonder, with two cruises coming up to plan for, if UMC would be able to come to an agreement with 80+ new bands for those two events.

[Stained Class]

I think it's typical practice for any festival not to have repeats from the previous year, but the year before could have some, except in the case of "house bands". If you look at Wacken there are a bunch of bands that basically play every second year, and then there's Subway To Sally who is the last band to play every year and they get fireworks and stuff.

[nekrobarr]

Hypocrisy can play 6 times, since they weren't on 2011 or 2012

I won't ask for anything else, and I would be there!

Only 6?

[DrinkMoxie]

Hypocrisy can play 6 times, since they weren't on 2011 or 2012

I won't ask for anything else, and I would be there!

Only 6?

yeah, Gnoff... would you not enjoy Hypocruisey, where they play 80 sets?

[Michaelage]

i would like me some pain or hypo... and the rest... it can be stolen... I WILL BE THERE AND I WILL ENJOY!!!!! woot

[KevinP]

i would like me some pain or hypo... and the rest... it can be stolen... I WILL BE THERE AND I WILL ENJOY!!!!! woot

what's mama smitty's status ???

[MadameLePink]

I think it's typical practice for any festival not to have repeats from the previous year, but the year before could have some, except in the case of "house bands". If you look at Wacken there are a bunch of bands that basically play every second year, and then there's Subway To Sally who is the last band to play every year and they get fireworks and stuff.

I know, but this is still a new festival and there are so many bands that haven't played there yet :) But we'll see what Andy thinks about that!

[Stained Class]

Only 6?

yeah, Gnoff... would you not enjoy Hypocruisey, where they play 80 sets?

If they play 24/7 that'd be cool, I might have to try coke, but for Hypocrisy that might be worth it?

Margarita & Red Bull every 3 hours.

[Stained Class]

I think it's typical practice for any festival not to have repeats from the previous year, but the year before could have some, except in the case of "house bands". If you look at Wacken there are a bunch of bands that basically play every second year, and then there's Subway To Sally who is the last band to play every year and they get fireworks and stuff.

I know, but this is still a new festival and there are so many bands that haven't played there yet :) But we'll see what Andy thinks about that!

I imagine he will try to have as original of a line up as possible, but having bands from last year isn't off the table. Depends on how things work out, we very well could have a 100% new lineup! Which would be cool!

[WizardBeast]

yeah, Gnoff... would you not enjoy Hypocruisey, where they play 80 sets?

If they play 24/7 that'd be cool, I might have to try coke, but for Hypocrisy that might be worth it?

OOOOHHH NOOOO! you might become controlled by aliens after such an ordeal! Gnoff Tägtgren!

[cowboy71]

Do you really think there will be repeats? I thought it was out of the question as there are many bands that would like to be onbroad :) Of course I would be thrilled if they announced Ensiferum, Finntroll, Korpiklaani, Amon Amarth, Testament and Dark Tranquillity

I'm not expecting a lot, just a couple. Many of the first cruise bands really want to play it again. I figure it would be easy to get them booked and Andy may even be able to give a couple of them a "lowball" offer to come back because they liked it so much. Could save some budget for headliner types. I wonder, with two cruises coming up to plan for, if UMC would be able to come to an agreement with 80+ new bands for those two events.

Yeah you raise some valid points.

I would have thought "wow finding ANOTHER 40 metal bands that enough people know about? impossible". That would have been before collating the following list though.

There are 500(!!) unique bands in the full list I've compiled of everyones' wishlists from this thread. 500! 315 with one vote, 88 with two, 39 with three, 18 with four, and the following 40 (yay we have a full boat LOL!) are all non-repeats (with a couple of repeat individuals - ie Jon Schaffer & Hansi, Fabio Leone):

13 - Helloween, Immortal, Kreator
12 - King Diamond/Merciful Fate
11 - Accept, Hypocrisy, Running Wild
09 - Arkona
08 - Opeth, Symphony X, Turisas, Powerwolf
07 - Arch Enemy, Enslaved, Heathen, Kalmah, Within Temptation
06 - Bolt Thrower, Crimson Glory, Devin Townsend/SYL, Madder Mortem, UneXpect, Heidevolk
05 - Agalloch, Anthrax, Anvil, Artillery, At The Gates, Demons & Wizards, Dethklok, Equillibrium, Falconer, Insomnium, Paradise Lost, Pentagram, Rhapsody of Fire, Rotting Christ, Satyricon, Septic Flesh, W.A.S.P.

[cowboy71]

Funnily enough - this list is actually TOO good for me

13 bands I would BADLY WANT to see twice, and 15 I would NEED to see at least once!! And a few I don't know of AT ALL that I may like after research.

Kind of cool that a list compiled from the collective minds of the forum could generate such an agreeable list for me.

What do others think?

[Stained Class]

Funnily enough - this list is actually TOO good for me

13 bands I would BADLY WANT to see twice, and 15 I would NEED to see at least once!! And a few I don't know of AT ALL that I may like after research.

Kind of cool that a list compiled from the collective minds of the forum could generate such an agreeable list for me.

What do others think?

I think that list would be great for everyone, seeing as the ones with the most votes ARE the ones that we all want to see

[Ravenlord]

I'm just going to take the time to update this because there are quite a few here that I would love:

14 - Helloween
13 - King Diamond/Merciful Fate, Immortal, Kreator
12 - Accept, Running Wild
11 - Hypocrisy
10 - Arkona
09 - Symphony X, Turisas, Powerwolf
08 - Opeth, Kalmah
07 - Bolt Thrower, Crimson Glory, Devin Townsend/SYL, Madder Mortem, Heidevolk, Arch Enemy, Enslaved, Heathen, Within Temptation
06 - Demons & Wizards, Dethklok, Equillibrium, Falconer, Rhapsody of Fire, UneXpect, W.A.S.P.
05 - Agalloch, Anthrax, Anvil, Artillery, At The Gates, Insomnium, Paradise Lost, Pentagram, Rotting Christ, Satyricon, Septic Flesh

Damn that took way too much work...