Chopper wrote:I was told from the beginning there was not going to be any up and coming bands. just established acts.
Captain Metal wrote:Yes, there will be karaoke AND open mic festivities in two separate areas of the ship, the latter being the more interesting of the two I believe.
Metalwrath wrote:Most so called 'up and coming bands' don't deserve any fucking support.One thing i have noticed that has plagued the metal scene over the more recent years if bands getting know due to support from frinds who don't actually like their music but come to the gig as support and try to make it look like the band has a big audiece which is entirely untrue.
I've listened to a lot of new bands and they are fucking terrible.Unfortuntatly somewhere over the last 10 years most bands have lost the ability to creativly make music of their owjn and instead end up recylcing maerial of old established metal bands.
cg138 wrote:I'm on Metalwrath's side on this one, though not entirely. Of course what he said doesn't pertain to every unsigned band, but I would agree that for the most part, almost all of the local "metal" bands (though it may obviously vary by your location) are just a badly attempted clone of an existing band. I would imagine anyone else from south florida agrees with this.
Element0s wrote:
So, about Samandriel and Viathyn playing some opening sets on the cruise...
viathyn wrote:Element0s wrote:
So, about Samandriel and Viathyn playing some opening sets on the cruise...
Well fuck me sideways that would kick ass!
KK Cruiser wrote:How about that band that won the Wacken Metal Battle? The Fading from Israel? They are great and certainly up and coming.
I guess I am old, but I need to SEE a band first, there is too much computer editing cheating going on now..
Element0s wrote:cg138 wrote:I'm on Metalwrath's side on this one, though not entirely. Of course what he said doesn't pertain to every unsigned band, but I would agree that for the most part, almost all of the local "metal" bands (though it may obviously vary by your location) are just a badly attempted clone of an existing band. I would imagine anyone else from south florida agrees with this.
Oh, I'm not saying that every single local level band is worth your time and you should attend every show you possibly can. But every single band that ever played a set of original tunes started out the same: By playing to their friends and family. At some point, your band will either improve and you'll find that more and more people come to your gigs and you get booked better shows at better venues. If your band sucks (or continues to suck) then you'll notice that, less and less of your friends and family will come out and you won't get booked for shows at bars very often. Generally bands that end up like that break up. As for the originality issue, that's something that has plagued and will forever plague the music scene as long as it exsists, so there's not much to say about that. As someone pointed out earlier, your mileage may vary depending on where you live. However, even the derivative worship bands in town can put on a fun rocking show and deliver some solid tunes!
My point being: Every band has to start somewhere, good or bad. It's not fair to ignore a band simply because they are on a local level (or because you saw them 2 years ago and they weren't very good back then) and it's definitely not fair to condemn a bands' friends/family for being there to support their loved ones.
So, about Samandriel and Viathyn playing some opening sets on the cruise...
Max_Rockwell wrote:Let's be honest though. Pretty much everything has already been done by previous musicians. Rob Zombie mentioned once that in Metal, everything was already done by Sabbath and any bands or musicians after that, just played variations of what they did, whether it'd be slower, faster, backwards, progressive etc...
A lot of "true" metalheads/musicians are quick to shut down the idea that maybe expanding their musicial horizons can bring something new to their music. Whether it'd be picking up or adding a new instrument to their basic 3 instrument set up, or adding elements from different genres of music. I gotta say that the bands that stand out to me today, are the ones that have taken that slight if not huge step outside the known metal music circle, and have expanded their music to the point where you know it represents a lot more than just heavy fast riffing and blast beats. But again, you tell someone who only listens to Immortal, and Celtic Frost to listen to something like Epica, Angra, or Eluveitie, and they'll be extremely fast to shut you down and perhaps even put you and those bands down. It's a real bummer that a lot of metalheads, and I say a lot because there are a lot, have to be like that.
Also, i'm not saying that every one is the same, for those of you who may have taken it the wrong way.
ShoreSlayer wrote:Yeah, you guys are onto it in a big way. It's a very sharply honed double-edge sword though. Read through some of the threads on this board alone and you can see how polarized people become when it comes to their tastes and opinions of various genres and sub-genres.
Many bands that combined traditional metal elements with something new like we saw through the 90's and beyond are slammed as garbage nu-core or mall-core or whatever. And fair enough. I'm not a big fan of what most of those bands did even though there are some that are incredibly talented and have some material that is far and away better than many of their critics could ever create themselves.
Then you get what I sort of think of as traditionalist bands that just worship what's been done and so don't try to expand on it but simply honour it by creating their own material in the same vein. Many listeners wind up appreciating and becoming big fans of these bands while others will condemn them for being unoriginal or merely copying what's been done before.
This sort of shows the lose/lose scenario I think most artists face if they set out trying to please fans, critics or anyone other than themselves.
Then you have what I think we'd all recognize as some of the cutting edges of metal where bands (from Europe mostly) are introducing a wide array of new instruments and traditional, cultural melodies and rhythms into their stuff and coming up with material most of us hadn't heard prior to that. I'm thinking of bands like Svartsot, Finntroll and Tyr but am no expert on them by any means and am sure I've excluded many that others would consider very obvious examples of the same thing. I think also that it won't be too long before we'll begin to see more and more bands employ instruments and themes from Eastern cultures that use notes outside of our traditional Western 12 note scale. Much of this is very foreign (pun required) to our ears and will alienate many listeners but will also likely introduce some amazing potential and result in some real killer tunes. I think this is an inevitable byproduct of our shrinking world.
Finally, and I think these are probably the artists who are most likely to continue to pave the way for some years, we have the bands that are similar to the traditionalists mentioned above but who push the boundaries in many directions. They don't necessarily bring in new instruments or unheard of, crazy time signatures or scales but they're just such well practiced and creative musicians that they find those hidden places inside of what's already been done and move beyond putting their own stamp on a classic sub-genre but take it to places it's yet to go. Tool is not my favourite band by any stretch but they're one of the best examples I can think of right now to illustrate my point. If a friend of yours had never heard them before, how would you describe them? Who can you compare them to? There's maybe a handful of bands that you can say they have elements of this and that but really, there's no other band like them. Some of Danny Carey's drumming is pretty amazing but I think their sound is unique more because of the combination of the talents combined and the very creative songwriting they've been able to achieve. I'm pretty sure any one of those guys could have been part of any old decent and successful metal band on their own. But, like them or not, what they stumbled upon together has really set them apart from the masses. Another much hated band that I think also stands out in a similar way is System of a Down. Or if a more metal example is needed, I'd submit someone like Enditol that Viathyn linked to in the what are you listening to now thread earlier today. I can see these guys coming up with something completely mind blowing in a few years.
So yeah, while pretty much everything has already been done, and there's only so many notes, rhythms and melodies to go around, I think there's still enough room for the cream of the crop to rise to the challenge and give us gifts that we never imagined. Now if only I had the chops and brilliance to be one of 'em
Max_Rockwell wrote:You should get yourself a simple keyboard and just hum out whatever comes to your head and try to match the notes in your head with the keyboard. :-p
Always a good way to start, and who knows, maybe you'll find something totally mind blowing.
But in any case...
ShoreSlayer wrote:Max_Rockwell wrote:You should get yourself a simple keyboard and just hum out whatever comes to your head and try to match the notes in your head with the keyboard. :-p
Always a good way to start, and who knows, maybe you'll find something totally mind blowing.
But in any case...
Hurting my brain trying to determine whether this is a dig or serious but I guess the only way to find out is to ask
Max_Rockwell wrote:I was being serious lol. I won't guarantee that it'll work, but always a start.ShoreSlayer wrote:Hurting my brain trying to determine whether this is a dig or serious but I guess the only way to find out is to ask
Could work with an acoustic guitar, but most people who are new to guitar complain and give up because their fingers are too tender :(. Boo hoo, keep playing damn it.
ShoreSlayer wrote:Max_Rockwell wrote:I was being serious lol. I won't guarantee that it'll work, but always a start.ShoreSlayer wrote:Hurting my brain trying to determine whether this is a dig or serious but I guess the only way to find out is to ask
Could work with an acoustic guitar, but most people who are new to guitar complain and give up because their fingers are too tender :(. Boo hoo, keep playing damn it.
Hahah... cool. Thanks for the clarification.
Yeah, I've actually been playin guitar for a long time. I was just referencing the fact that overall, but especially compared to the kinds of talents who might stand a chance of creating something completely original and groundbreaking, I'm just not that skilled
Max_Rockwell wrote:It's not nearly about skill as it is about desire and passion. :-p
Mozart wasn't very skilled, or at least not technical but he had the passion and drive. I don't think he knew he would be one of the greatest composers before he became one.
Max_Rockwell wrote:Regardless, bring whatever skills you got to the cruise and we'll jam it out. Hopefully they'll let me bring an acoustic, cause I plan to!
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 185 guests
70000TONS, 70000TONS OF METAL and the 70000TONS OF METAL logo are registered trademarks of Properties of Metal Ltd. and are used under license.
© 2009-2023 UMCruises International Ltd. All Rights Reserved.